The Wire: Crash, Imports, and Our Next Move
The last few weeks in the cattle market have been a gut punch. You’ve seen the headlines: Futures contracts plummeting, politicians talking about cheap imports, and a nasty parasite inching toward the border. It’s enough to make a farmer wonder if all the high prices were worth the stress.
But here in Ohio, we need to see this moment not as a crash, but as a critical turning point for our regional food system.
The Problem: Fear vs. Fundamentals
The national cattle market is experiencing a massive disconnect.
The Fear: Live cattle futures are tumbling. This is fueled by high-profile government talk about easing import quotas and reopening borders to foreign cattle. The market is panicking over the possibility of a supply glut, not the reality. The mere prospect of a flood of Mexican cattle—currently stalled by a New World Screwworm alert near the border—has sent speculators running.
The Fundamental Reality: The U.S. cattle herd is at its smallest inventory in nearly 75 years [1]. Meanwhile, retail beef prices are up sharply, showing that consumer demand remains strong [2]. This futures crash looks like a speculative over-correction fueled by worry, not fundamentals. It is a reminder that politics can outweigh supply and demand in the short run.
The Ohio Opportunity
This volatility hits Ohio producers—especially cow-calf and feeder operations—hard, making it tough to decide whether to sell now or invest in rebuilding. However, this national crisis hands Ohio a golden opportunity for local growth:
The Call to Grow: Herd Rebuilding The long-term play is clear: Ohio needs more cows. The national shortage means demand for Ohio-raised cattle will only grow stronger over the next several years.
Action for Farmers: Farmers currently in cash crops (corn, soybeans) or dairy who are looking to diversify should consider shifting acreage to pasture and investing in a small beef herd. This leverages high market prices and creates a reliable, high-value product.
The Heifer Dilemma: For existing ranchers, the difficult choice remains: sell those high-priced heifers now, or hold them back to expand the breeding herd for future, sustained profitability. We need the assurance that comes with a diversified local system.
Local Control: Abattoirs and Processing The supply chain disruption exposed one of Ohio's biggest weaknesses: the lack of local processing capacity. When large packers had issues, farmers often had nowhere to take their market-ready animals, causing chaos and a huge loss of value.
What We Need: We must prioritize more local, USDA-inspected abattoirs and small-to-midsize processing facilities. This insulates our producers from national market swings, allows farmers to sell direct-to-consumer for a better price, and keeps the food dollar right here in the state.
Action for Policy: Programs like the Ohio Meat Processing Grant must be continuously expanded to lower the high cost of entry for building or expanding these critical local businesses.
Securing the Future: Resources and Biosecurity We must strategically use available resources to support this growth. Farmers should utilize programs like the USDA’s Environmental Quality Incentives Program (EQIP) to help finance herd expansion through rotational grazing infrastructure (fencing, water systems).
Finally, while the Screwworm threat is at the southern border, Ohio producers must remain on guard. Any detection would trigger massive restrictions. Always immediately report any suspicious wounds or parasites to your local veterinarian or the State Animal Health Official.
This current volatility is painful, but it is also a signal. The market wants American beef, and our national supply is low. For Ohio, the answer isn't to fear the dip; it’s to invest strategically in the local infrastructure and the herds that will secure our future as a key player in the nation's beef supply.
What's your take? Are we overreacting to the market tumble, or is the political pressure going to fundamentally alter the cattle trade this winter?
Footnotes
[1] U.S. Department of Agriculture, National Agricultural Statistics Service (NASS). July 2025 Cattle Inventory Report, showing the lowest total cattle inventory since 1951.
[2] U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS). Consumer Price Index (CPI) data for August 2025, reporting beef and veal prices up approximately 13.9% year-over-year.
Comments